31 August 2009

First Page Game #8

The Stars Below

‘..........happy birthday to you. Go on, Lucianne, blow the candles out.’
The room had been a sea of children’s faces, flickeringly lit by reflected light from the ten candles sputtering on the pink candy cake, when the phone had rung, drawing him away from the celebrations.

‘Cameron? We need you out on the New Kingston Exploration platform. There’s a helicopter waiting in Aberdeen and a car will be with you in fifteen minutes’

That had been it.

A manic drive through dark roads and dimly lit watery suburbs to the airport where a sleek, private helicopter was already warmed up. Someone thrust a package of paperwork onto him as he suited up – ‘This’ll help explain the rush’ – and then it was in and away into the black night.

New Kingston was operating way beyond established platforms in the North Sea. Initial deep seismic investigation had looked promising but the reports and printouts for the current test bore were crazy – huge pressure differentials within the bore column, magnetic anomalies, distorted and fractured heads, power outages, equipment failures – what was going on?

Suddenly his stomach fell away. The turbine roar was replaced by silence, by a cacophony of alarms, by, a matter of fact - ‘Brace –we’re going in’ – and then it was like hitting a wall.


The writing is good and carries me along nicely, but I'm afraid I have little idea what's going on. And if I don't know what's going on, it makes it tough for me to care. Obscurity starts with the line "That had been it." Yes, the elusive, secretive "it" has reared its (no pun intended) ugly head again. I think we've been pretty clear that we're not crazy about this device. I'd rather see a story problem right there in that line, something to explain what "it" is. "They'd discovered the aliens." "The sea floor had gulped down several hundred oil-rig workers like they were minnows." See how even those bad examples are more interesting than "it"? Mechanical and technical malfunctions are only mildly interesting without some major impact on people or situation. IMO, not knowing the situation hurts this opening.

And yeah, I realize your POV character might not know yet either, but you've pretty well ruined that with "That had been it."

But that's only one strike in the midst of what appears to be some competent writing. I'd read on to see if the story problem manifests itself quickly, within a page or two.

20 comments:

lesleylsmith said...

Thanks for playing, Author! We appreciate it. I agree with Editor Betsy that the writing is good here and carries one along nicely. And I agree that I don't know what's going on. Bummer. :(

The birthday party scene is too brief to be understandable. If the author needs it to flesh out the protagonist's home life, maybe it would work better as a flashback?
Additionally, the phone call at the beginning is a cliche. I've blogged about phone calls before: do not start your story with a phone call.

That being said, beginning the story with "A manic drive through the dark roads and dimly lit watery suburbs..." could work great. That would be a story I'd really like to read!
Good luck, Author!

writtenwyrdd said...

I've got to agree, we need the problem stated. You don't have to tell us everything, but you need to tell us something to create the hook that makes us want to read more. There are several uses of 'it', so I think this might be an unconscious habit of yours, author.

This example is good writing, but not hooking me. I would have read on a bit, but any more uses of 'it' and I might not feel the same way. :)

Thanks for sharing!

Sarah Laurenson said...

Most of what I thought has been said. I'm not fond of the 'had' usage. I'm not grounded in where he is now and getting all the 'this is what happened to get me to this unspecified here' isn't drawing me into the story.

That had been it. is where I would stop reading and put it down. I'm afraid my patience level, or maybe it's my lack of free time, keeps me from giving what I read much of a chance to pull me in.

Anonymous said...

Buy [url=http://buy-cialis.icr38.net/Omnicef]omnicef online[/url] now - Discount Offer flomax online here - Grandiose Chance

Anonymous said...

Low price World delivery [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buycialisprofessionalonlineeasy]Buy Cialis Professional Online[/url] Buy Prednisone Online Online RX [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buypenisolonlineeasy]Buy Penisol Online[/url] Buy Tadacip Online
Sale Visa/Mastercard/Amex/eCheck [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buynorvasconlineeasy]Buy Norvasc Online[/url] Buy Cialis Online

Anonymous said...

ED ED [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyprozaconlineeasy]Buy Prozac Online[/url] Buy Levitra Online Buy Without prescription [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyvpxlonlineeasy]Buy Vpxl Online[/url] Buy Nolvadex Online
50mg Cheap [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyphentermineonlineeasy]Buy Phentermine Online[/url] Buy Valium Online

Anonymous said...

Now No prescription [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buypriloseconlineeasy]Buy Prilosec Online[/url] Buy Cialis Soft Online Without prescription ED [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyprednisoneonlineeasy]Buy Prednisone Online[/url] Buy Augmentin Online
No prescription Order [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buynolvadexonlineeasy]Buy Nolvadex Online[/url] Buy Tramadol Online

Anonymous said...

Low price Discount [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyzithromaxonlineeasy]Buy Zithromax Online[/url] Buy Cialis Soft Online Get Generic [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyvpxlonlineeasy]Buy Vpxl Online[/url] Buy Differin Online
Buy Discount [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyfemaleviagraonlineeasy]Buy Female Viagra Online[/url] Buy Levitra Online

Anonymous said...

Side-effects 10mg [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyprednisoneonlineeasy]Buy Prednisone Online[/url] Buy Propecia Online Canadian Canadian [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buypenisolonlineeasy]Buy Penisol Online[/url] Buy Lasix Online
World shipping Drug [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyelavilonlineeasy]Buy Elavil Online[/url] Buy Tramadol Online

Anonymous said...

50mg Pharmacy [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buycialisonlineeasy]Buy Cialis Online[/url] Buy Differin Online Now Without prescription [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buyelavilonlineeasy]Buy Elavil Online[/url] Buy Penisol Online
World delivery Visa/Mastercard/Amex/eCheck [url=http://stores.lulu.com/buynorvasconlineeasy]Buy Norvasc Online[/url] Buy Doxycycline Online

Anonymous said...

oHXiSA sumycin sale lJWBdI microzide free pills nRhYow claritin no prescription MIJifx lanoxin now XwKNch maxolon buy TQvGTh forzest ed GZgVNg imuran order

Anonymous said...

WNtuRh mestinon order dMEfkR cordarone world delivery cnhpjp provera pharmacy FsgqMK phentermine cheap xRdwFZ diflucan online PabydQ zithromax free pills XTYolI zyprexa online

Anonymous said...

AwyQQZ mexitil no prescription gXwdln grifulvin v low price CounvM phentermine 10mg wGDOUi diamox get weyixm aceon visa/mastercard/amex/echeck olWRnB selsun side-effects wlnXpK diovan generic

Anonymous said...

YbQQFY pulmicort 25mg ftznQt abana world delivery LApjpM acai berry discount uuTMxE accupril 10mg UNDfNo accutane sale joChxo aceon buy xGHIQB aciphex now

Anonymous said...

FLYfjk hytrin ed NfRXQG premarin 50mg lhgEZy ceclor order iThjht septilin online LHqPrL lotrisone 50mg jjKkfP minipress visa/mastercard/amex/echeck nxfKQh biaxin discount

Anonymous said...

comment 3, [url=http://buycarafateonline.tumblr.com]order carafate[/url]. comment 1, buy carafate liquid http://buycarafateonline.tumblr.com buy carafate liquid
comment 2, [url=http://buyesidrixonline.tumblr.com]esidrix online[/url]. comment 6, esidrix purchase http://buyesidrixonline.tumblr.com esidrix purchase
comment 8, [url=http://buyalesseonline.tumblr.com]buy alesse online[/url]. comment 2, alesse cheap http://buyalesseonline.tumblr.com order alesse birth control pills

Anonymous said...

comment 7, [url=http://buycarafateonline.tumblr.com]order carafate[/url]. comment 6, buy carafate online canada http://buycarafateonline.tumblr.com cheap carafate
comment 7, [url=http://buyesidrixonline.tumblr.com]esidrix online[/url]. comment 5, online esidrix http://buyesidrixonline.tumblr.com purchase esidrix
comment 8, [url=http://buyalesseonline.tumblr.com]alesse purchase[/url]. comment 6, alesse birth control buy online http://buyalesseonline.tumblr.com buy alesse online no prescription

Anonymous said...

comment 4, [url=http://buydilantinonline.tumblr.com]buy dilaudid no prescription[/url]. comment 9, dilantin backorder http://buydilantinonline.tumblr.com buy dilantin online
comment 7, [url=http://buybrafixonline.tumblr.com]brafix purchase[/url]. comment 7, buy brafix online http://buybrafixonline.tumblr.com buy brafix online
comment 6, [url=http://buyrulideonline.tumblr.com]rulide order[/url]. comment 6, rulide purchase http://buyrulideonline.tumblr.com rulide buy

Anonymous said...

comment 7, [url=http://buyoxybutynin.tumblr.com]oxybutynine online[/url]. comment 9, oxybutynin purchase online http://buyoxybutynin.tumblr.com oxybutynin online pharmacy
comment 7, [url=http://buyneoralonline.tumblr.com]purchase neoral[/url]. comment 6, buy nizoral http://buyneoralonline.tumblr.com buy sandimmune neoral
comment 3, [url=http://buyaltace.tumblr.com]order altace[/url]. comment 3, buy altace http://buyaltace.tumblr.com buy altace online

Anonymous said...

comment 6, [url=http://buydoxycyclineonline.bligoo.com]doxycycline order canada[/url]. comment 8, doxycycline online purchase http://buydoxycyclineonline.bligoo.com order doxycycline hyclate 100mg
comment 2, [url=http://buytrimoxonline.bligoo.com]order trimox[/url]. comment 4, trimox buy http://buytrimoxonline.bligoo.com trimox cheap
comment 3, [url=http://buyatomoxetineonline.bligoo.com]atomoxetine buy online uk[/url]. comment 9, atomoxetine buy uk http://buyatomoxetineonline.bligoo.com purchase atomoxetine